Back to results mode

Without telling Phillip or Hollie anything, Ryan decides to take a look back at Joshua's Wednesday performances.

Jimmy thinks You Raise Me Up works best in high-school graduations, not with full-gospel renditions of American Idol. "You can't use that trick every time on every song," he says. "In my opinion, You Raise Me Up let him down."

As for his James Brown cover, it was "a piece of magic that is...